Federal Complaint Alleges Bainbridge Island School District Ignored Teacher’s Abuse

A federal civil rights and negligence lawsuit filed against the Bainbridge Island School District paints a deeply disturbing picture of an institution that allegedly left a vulnerable teenage girl at the mercy of a teacher she accuses of abuse.

The civil complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington, centers on the harrowing ordeal of a former Bainbridge High School student, identified in court documents as A.A.

U.S. District Court Complaint

The lawsuit claims A.A. was targeted, groomed, and sexually abused by her former chemistry teacher, Steve Hohl. According to the Bainbridge Island Review, Hohl retired from the school district in 2005. He also coached wrestling.

The complaint alleges the sexual contact began during A.A.’s junior year, when she was just 16 years old.

A Culture of Abuse

While the allegations against the former teacher are chilling, the lawsuit directs its sharpest criticism at the school district itself, which is the sole named defendant in the case.

The complaint asserts that district administrators “knew or should have known” that Hohl was a “pervasive pedophile” who preyed upon younger female students.

U.S. District Court Complaint

Instead of intervening and protecting the students in their care, the district allegedly allowed the teacher to maintain his position of power, fostering what the complaint describes as a “toxic and misogynistic culture of abuse.”

For parents, the concept of in loco parentis—the legal responsibility of a school to act in the place of a parent while a child is in its custody—is the bedrock of the educational system.

The lawsuit argues that the Bainbridge Island School District catastrophically breached this duty.

By allegedly ignoring open and obvious alarming behavior, the district, the lawsuit claims, enabled an environment where abuse could flourish unchecked.

Potential for Additional Victims

Perhaps most troubling is the lawsuit’s claim that A.A. may not be the only victim. Court documents state that Steve Hohl is alleged to have sexually abused several other students who attended Bainbridge High School.

A joint status report filed by the attorneys explicitly references two other parallel cases currently proceeding in Kitsap County Superior Court involving the district and the same former teacher.

Furthermore, the complaint states that when deposed under oath in related proceedings, Hohl invoked his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination when asked if he had sexual contact with A.A..

U.S. District Court Complaint

The District’s Defense

The Bainbridge Island School District, for its part, has flatly denied the allegations of wrongdoing.

In its formal answer to the complaint, the district argues that even if Hohl’s alleged conduct occurred, it fell outside the course and scope of his employment, suggesting the district itself should not be held liable.

The district also asserts standard affirmative defenses, including claims that the lawsuit is barred by the statute of limitations.

Looking Ahead to Trial

As the case marches toward a scheduled 15-day jury trial set for March 16, 2027, the community is left grappling with unsettling questions.

Late last month, the court entered a protective order to ensure sensitive student and personnel records remain confidential during the ongoing discovery process.

The outcome of this lawsuit may ultimately yield financial compensation for A.A., who is seeking damages for severe emotional distress and the deprivation of her educational opportunities.