The Washington Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday that the state Growth Management Hearings Board erred when it dismissed, without analysis, a challenge to the water protections in Kitsap County's 2024 comprehensive plan update, and sent the dispute back to the board for a new decision.
The unanimous, unpublished Division II decision vacates the portion of the board's order addressing the claim, which was brought by the land-use advocacy group Futurewise.
The court did not decide whether the county's water regulations comply with state law.
The case arises under the Growth Management Act, which requires counties to adopt comprehensive plans and development regulations and to periodically review and, if needed, revise them. Those plans must include provisions protecting groundwater and surface water.
Kitsap County completed periodic reviews in 2016 and 2024. Between those reviews, the opinion notes, the Legislature changed the act twice.
In January 2018, lawmakers enacted RCW 36.70A.590. The statute says counties may rely on or refer to the Department of Ecology's minimum instream flow rules, and that development regulations must ensure proposed water uses are consistent with specified state water laws and rules.
In 2023, lawmakers amended the act's environmental goal by adding the words "and enhance," so that the goal is now to protect and enhance the environment, including air and water quality and the availability of water.
In February 2018, a month after the first change, the county adopted Ordinance 551-2018, which requires building permit applicants to provide evidence of an adequate water supply.
For building sites served by a permit-exempt well constructed on or after January 19, 2018, the ordinance limits the annual average withdrawal to 950 gallons per day per connection for domestic use.
The county's 2024 review produced Ordinance 637-2024, which adopted an updated comprehensive plan and amended certain development regulations.
Futurewise petitioned the board to review the 2024 ordinance on several grounds. One of them, which the board labeled Issue 13, asked whether the plan and regulations protect surface and groundwater as the Growth Management Act requires.
Futurewise argued that nothing in the updated plan or regulations limited withdrawals from permit-exempt wells to 5,000 gallons per day, a limit it contended the 2018 statute requires.
It also argued the county had failed to improve its land use regulations to protect hydrology, as it said the amended environmental goal demands.
The county responded that it had no obligation to revise its water regulations in 2024 because the 2018 ordinance had already brought it into compliance. It also argued that the 2018 statute permits, but does not require, counties to incorporate instream flow rules.
Futurewise replied that the 2018 ordinance did not bring the county into compliance with the statute.
At the hearing, the county also argued that any challenge to the 2018 ordinance was time-barred. Futurewise countered that the county had not produced a publication date for the ordinance and therefore could not show the deadline had passed.
It also emphasized that the 2018 ordinance placed no limit at all on withdrawals from wells built before 2018 and did not cap permit-exempt wells at 5,000 gallons per day.
The board declined to consider the 2018 ordinance, finding that issues related to it were not properly before the board because the petition concerned the 2024 ordinance.
It then dismissed Issue 13, stating that Futurewise had not convinced it the ordinance was clearly erroneous. The board later denied Futurewise's motion for reconsideration.
Presiding Judge Bradley Maxa, writing for the panel, agreed with the board on one point. To the extent Futurewise was attacking the validity of the 2018 ordinance itself, the board was right not to rule, because the petition's statement of issues identified only the 2024 ordinance and the board may not issue advisory opinions on issues not presented to it.
But the panel accepted Futurewise's position that it was not trying to invalidate the 2018 ordinance. It was the county that relied on that ordinance as its defense.
To evaluate that defense, the court said, the board had to address whether the 2018 ordinance satisfied, or even addressed, the requirements of the 2018 statute. If it did not, the county may have been required to modify its plan or regulations in 2024.
Even though Futurewise's petition never mentioned the 2018 ordinance, its adequacy was "directly at issue," Maxa wrote.
The court also held that the board failed to decide all of the issues requiring resolution. State law requires the board to issue written decisions articulating the basis for its holdings.
The board's order, the opinion said, summarily rejected Futurewise's challenge to the 2024 ordinance with no analysis and no citation to the record or to legal authority.
The panel added that it was not entirely clear which ordinance the board meant when it said Futurewise had failed to show clear error.
The opinion says several potentially dispositive issues went unaddressed and lists six that may be among them.
They include what the 2018 statute and the 2023 amendment required of the county during its 2024 review, and whether the 2018 ordinance made further revisions to water-related regulations unnecessary.
The county argued that Futurewise was not harmed by any shortcoming in the board's order because the law supports the county's position on the merits. The court disagreed, concluding that resolving the open questions may result in Futurewise prevailing.
The county also asked the appeals court to decide those questions itself. The panel declined, saying remand was particularly appropriate because the board was created to interpret issues arising under the Growth Management Act and courts defer to its specialized knowledge.
Because the court concluded the board never ruled that a challenge to the 2018 ordinance was time-barred, it did not address Futurewise's arguments on that point.
Futurewise had sought judicial review in Thurston County Superior Court, and the petition was transferred directly to the Court of Appeals. Futurewise's other challenges to the 2024 ordinance were not part of the appeal.
Judges Linda Lee and Meng Li Che concurred. The court expressed no opinion on the merits of the questions it sent back to the board.
↺ Republish this story
Our stories are free to republish, online or in print, under these rules:
- Credit The Olympic Herald and the author, and link back to this story.
- Don't edit the story except for style, length, or to update time references.
- If you republish online, use our canonical URL so search engines credit the original.
- Don't sell the story or use it primarily to sell advertising.
Questions? Contact us.