The Washington State Commission on Judicial Conduct admonished Mason County Superior Court Judge Monty D. Cobb on November 20 for telling a courtroom filled with members of the Skokomish Tribe that he saw “way too many acts of violence from the Native community.”

Cobb made the remark at a Feb. 13 manslaughter sentencing. The victim and the defendant were longtime friends, relatives by marriage and members of the tribe.

Some tribal members came in support of the victim and others in support of the defendant. Witnesses told commission investigators they heard a gasp after Cobb spoke.

The commission received two complaints alleging that the remark showed bias against Native Americans.

The commission said Cobb’s words reinforced a stereotype about crime and left listeners feeling he blamed the community for the violence its members had suffered.

Witnesses also told investigators they believed Cobb treated people fairly in his courtroom and held no bias against Indigenous people.

According to the stipulated facts, some tribal members told police and prosecutors they believed racism had tainted the investigation and prosecution.

The defendant had faced a second-degree murder charge before pleading guilty to second-degree manslaughter.

He had no prior criminal history. Under the plea agreement, prosecutors could ask for up to 78 months in prison. Cobb imposed a sentence above the standard range of 21 to 27 months.

In an Aug. 15 letter to the commission, Cobb said a statement submitted on behalf of the victim’s children prompted him to read about missing and murdered Indigenous people.

He said he wanted the victim’s family to know he had heard them and regretted that his words had caused pain in the community.

The commission accepted Cobb’s account of what he meant. It said the research he cited documented how often Indigenous people suffer violence and offered no basis for suggesting they commit it at higher rates.

Cobb admitted violating Rules 1.1 and 1.2 of the Code of Judicial Conduct, which require judges to comply with the law and act in ways that sustain public confidence in their impartiality.

He also agreed that his remark gave the appearance of violating Rule 2.3(B), which bars judges from showing bias or prejudice in their official duties.

Admonishment is the commission’s least severe sanction. Cobb has served on the Mason County bench since 2018 and has no prior disciplinary history.

The commission said he accepted responsibility and cooperated fully. It found no evidence of a pattern of similar conduct.

Cobb agreed to read the entire Code of Judicial Conduct and confirm in writing within 30 days that he had done so.

Read the commission’s order and Judge Cobb’s response.

Share this article
The link has been copied!
Republish this story

Our stories are free to republish, online or in print, under these rules:

  • Credit The Olympic Herald and the author, and link back to this story.
  • Don't edit the story except for style, length, or to update time references.
  • If you republish online, use our canonical URL so search engines credit the original.
  • Don't sell the story or use it primarily to sell advertising.

Questions? Contact us.